|
“I love you just the way you are.” It’s what Mark Darcy (almost) famously says to Bridget Jones, his paramour, near the end of Bridget Jones’s Diary — a film I love to absolute bits despite its (many) flaws. But while I’ve spent more than one Christmas watching and rewatching Bridget — and even talking over it to complain... I’ve noticed that, lately, I’ve been trading in this straight romantic fantasy for its queer version. Because the fantasy in queer films is a parent (or parental figure) who tells you this — only it's I love you just the way you are. In Pride (2014), it’s a mother figure wishing Gethin Happy Christmas in Welsh because his mother can’t — which leads to him finally returning home to Wales to declare, “I’m in Wales! And I don’t have to pretend to be something that I'm not! I'm home! And I'm gay! And I'm Welsh!” In Call Me by Your Name, it’s Elio’s father telling him: he sees the friendship that was something more with Oliver, and he wants Elio to treasure it. And then, at Christmas, it’s the way his parents treat Oliver (on the phone) like a son-in-law because they’ve already accepted him as family — something Oliver says he would never get from his parents. And in All of Us Strangers, it’s Adam’s mom singing along to the lyrics of Pet Shop Boys’ “Always on My Mind,” quietly apologizing for her shortcomings as a parent in the only way she can: “Maybe I didn't treat you Quite as good as I should Maybe I didn't love you Quite as often as I could Little things I should have said and done I never took the time You were always on my mind You were always on my mind.” Because the queer fantasy of acceptance is one we can all get behind — even if it’s not something the world always offers. But film can be a consolation, too, even when it isn’t offering a fantasy. I’ve been thinking about this a lot this year, thanks to Joachim Trier’s new film Sentimental Value (the year's very best film now on VOD!), which isn’t a queer film but offers a different, equally important catharsis. Sentimental Value refuses to give in to the fantasy (except perhaps in the film within a film) of a (in this case, narcissistic) parent even recognizing their shortcomings, let alone doing anything about them. It offers something instead: that catharsis doesn’t always come from the people we think we need it from, but can be achieved nonetheless. Which is kind of a bitter pill, but a hopeful one, too, perhaps because it’s a realistic one. And yet it’s also the inverse of Trier’s first masterpiece (and my favourite film), Oslo, August 31st — where, like an Aristotelian tragedy, the catharsis doesn’t happen onscreen, but with us, the audience. (And I find it hugely life-affirming because real life so rarely delivers that catharsis — but the film still does!) In the new year, I’ll be diving into Oslo, August 31st and Sentimental Value — and how they build catharsis through film form — in a new offer called The Deep Focus. But for now… Wishing you whatever kind of closure, comfort, or catharsis you need today. Happy Christmas! Alex |
Seventh Row is a nonprofit Canadian film criticism publication and publishing house. We're dedicated to helping you expand your horizons by curating the best socially progressive films from around the world and helping you think deeply about them. This newsletter is run by Seventh Row (http://seventh-row.com) but features exclusive content not found on the website.
Chloé Zhao's Hamnet is a top contender for the Oscars. But while many found themselves weeping for large chunks of the film, I left dry-eyed. So did my guest on today’s podcast, Angelo Muredda. (And we’re easy criers. So we tried to figure out why this film didn’t work for us.) Based on Maggie O’Farrell’s novel — which imagines a part of Shakespeare’s life we know little about, including the courtship with his wife, the death of their son Hamnet, and the possible autobiographical links to...
I recently learned about the term “Second Screen.” It describes a kind of TV made to be watched while you’re also on your phone.(Think: easy-to-follow dialogue, minimal visual complexity, no real consequences for tuning out.) And I’ve noticed I’m getting trained by it. I’ll start a show like Matlock or Industry with the intention of paying attention. By the final episodes, I’m just listening to it on my phone while I make dinner. My phone is in my pocket. And honestly, it seems like nobody...
I have a theory that when you see a film that changes you — that makes you feel seen in a whole new way or reorganizes how you think — you remember where you were when it happened. You remember the cinema you saw it in (or the couch you were sitting on). You remember who you were with. When a film feels like a discovery, you remember the exact conditions that made it possible for you to even see that movie. Maybe most crucially, you remember where you were in life at that moment that made you...